← Back to course
Weather Lab 6-8 / Week 02 / Wednesday
3/6
Week 02 Β· The Sun Heats the Earth Unevenly

Wednesday

Station Lab: Land versus water
// Energy from the Sun, and why some places get more of it
⏱ about 20 min

Wednesday: Station Lab: Land Versus Water

Rocket lines up two cups on the sunny railing. One holds soil, the other water. "Race!" he says.

Raven checks both with the thermometer. "Same temperature to start. What do you notice about the cups?"

"Same size, same color, same amount," Rocket says. "I made sure. Otherwise it is not a fair race."

Nova settles beside them. "A fair test changes one thing only," she says. "What is the one thing here?"

"Soil or water," Raven says. "Everything else stays the same."

An hour later, Rocket reads the thermometer and his eyes go wide. "The soil won by a lot."

"Now put them in the shade," Nova says. "Which one do you predict will cool faster?"

Your mission

You will plan and run a fair test: does soil or water warm faster in sunlight, and which cools faster in shade?

In a fair test you change only one thing. NASA's science fair guide calls that one thing the variable.

Only by keeping everything else the same can you be sure the variable is what you are testing.

Scientists name the parts of a test. The thing you change is the independent variable: soil or water.

The thing you measure is the dependent variable: temperature. Everything you keep the same is a control.

  • Two identical cups, same size and same color
  • Dry soil from a garden or a plant pot, and tap water
  • A digital or alcohol thermometer the family already has (or use your hand, see the steps)
  • A sunny spot and a shady spot, on the ground, a railing or a windowsill
  • A clock and your weather log
Safety first
Never look at the Sun. Watch the thermometer and the clock, not the sky.
Use only a digital or alcohol thermometer, never a mercury one. If the family has none, compare by touch.
Wash your hands after touching soil. Nothing from this lab goes in your mouth.
The cups sit on the ground, a railing or a windowsill, never on a roof or ladder.
  1. Fill one cup with soil and the other with water to the same depth, about two fingers from the top.
  2. Let both cups sit indoors for ten minutes so they start at the same temperature. Record that starting temperature.
  3. Put both cups in the same sunny spot at the same moment. Write down the time.
  4. After 30 minutes, measure each cup. Push the thermometer tip just under the surface, the same depth in each.
  5. After 60 minutes, measure again and record both numbers.
  6. Move both cups to the same shady spot. Measure after 30 minutes in the shade.
  7. No thermometer? Touch the side of each cup with the back of your hand and write "warmer" or "cooler".
TimeSoil cup temperatureWater cup temperatureWhich is warmer?
Start (indoors)
30 minutes in sun
60 minutes in sun
30 minutes in shade
PREDICT BEFORE YOU MEASURE
  • Read the question.
  • Tap your answer.
The National Weather Service says sunlight stays in the top few inches of soil but goes deep into water. Which cup do you predict warms faster?
Which part of this test is the independent variable, the one thing you change?

What the Weather Service says

The National Weather Service explains that the Sun warms land and water at the same rate, but the results differ.

The Sun's rays are confined to the top few inches of soil. In clear water, light can reach hundreds of feet down.

Wind and waves also keep mixing the water, spreading the heat through a huge volume.

So it takes a great amount of heat to raise the temperature of water, and it holds that heat longer.

The result: temperature swings between day and night are much greater over land than over water.

The thing you measure in this test is the ____ variable.
Sunlight is confined to the top few ____ of soil.
Day-to-night temperature swings are greater over ____ than over water.
What the lab showsTrue or false?
A fair test changes only one thing at a time.?
Using two different sized cups would still be a fair test.?
Sunlight reaches much deeper into water than into soil.?
Water warms faster than soil in the same sunlight.?
WHY THIS EXERCISEThe lab only means something if you can say what was tested and what was controlled.
On paper, sketch your two cups in the Sun. Show with short arrows how deep the sunlight reaches in each one.
For a grown-up
The cups can sit on a windowsill if there is no safe outdoor spot. A sunny window works well.
A thermometer is optional. Comparing by touch is fine; the lesson is about designing a fair test.

Real data from a fair test. Tomorrow you read NASA's budget for the whole planet's sunlight.

← Tuesday