Rocket has three ice cubes lined up on three plates. "Sun, shade and the coolest corner of the house," he says.
"Are they the same size?" Raven asks. Rocket looks closer. One is clearly bigger. "Oops."
He trades it for a matching cube from the same tray. "Now it is fair."
Nova hovers over the plates, her light steady. "What are you changing on purpose?" she asks. "And what are you keeping the same?"
"Changing the spot," Rocket says. "Keeping the cube size, the plate and the start time the same."
"And what are you measuring?" Raven asks. "How long each one takes to melt," he says, starting the timer.
Raven writes three columns in the Bench Log: Spot, Start time, Melted at.
Today you plan and run an investigation: in which spot does an ice cube melt fastest, and why?
A fair test changes one thing on purpose. Here, that is the spot. Everything else stays the same.
The thing you change is called the independent variable. The thing you measure, the time to melt, is the dependent variable.
The things you keep the same, such as cube size and plate type, are called controls.
If you have a thermometer, you will also watch a cup of water. You will record how its temperature changes as ice melts in it.
| Spot | Prediction (1st, 2nd, 3rd) | Start time | Completely melted at | Minutes to melt |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Warm or sunny spot | ||||
| Room temperature spot | ||||
| Coolest spot |
| Time (minutes) | Water temperature | What the ice looks like |
|---|---|---|
| 0 (before the ice) | ||
| 2 | ||
| 4 | ||
| 6 |
Heat flowed from the warmer air into each ice cube. Where the air was warmer, more energy flowed in, and the cube melted sooner.
As the ice melted, its temperature did not rise. All the energy going in was used to break the particles loose from their fixed positions.
In the cup, heat flowed from the warmer water into the colder ice. The water lost thermal energy, so its temperature went down.
A fair test with controls lets you say the spot, and nothing else, caused the difference.
| What the lab shows | True or false? |
|---|---|
| The cube in the warmest spot melted first. | ? |
| Using cubes of different sizes would still be a fair test. | ? |
| The time to melt is the dependent variable. | ? |
| The water in the cup warmed up when ice was added. | ? |
Excellent investigation. Tomorrow you will read the melting and boiling points of real substances and see how yours compares.