← Back to course
Bike Shop 3-5 / Week 12 / Monday
1/6
Week 12 Β· Design a Better Bike

Monday

Name the problem
// Define, compare, test, improve
⏱ about 15 min

Monday: Name the Problem

Rocket balances a stack of library books on his handlebars. They slide and wobble.

"I need a giant rocket booster basket!" he says.

Raven tilts her head. "What do you notice? What is the real problem here?"

Nova hovers above the books. "Engineers name the problem before they build," she says.

Rocket opens his shop notebook to the last section: Design Lab.

Engineers start with a problem

Engineers solve problems that come from people's needs and wants.

First they define the problem clearly.

Criteria are what the design must do to be a success.

Constraints are the limits, like materials and time.

A good problem statement names both.

ProblemOne criterion (must do)One constraint (limit)
Carrying books on a bikeHolds books without slidingCardboard and tape only
Being seen by othersShows up when light shines on itMust be done in one week
Rain on a backpackKeeps paper inside dryUses things found at home
CRITERIA OR CONSTRAINT?
  • Read the question.
  • Tap your answer.
The basket must hold three books. Is that a criterion or a constraint?
You may only use cardboard and tape. Criterion or constraint?
You have one week to finish. Criterion or constraint?
What word means the limits on a design?
WHY THIS EXERCISEConstraints are limits, like materials and time.
StatementTrue or false?
Engineers define the problem before building.?
Criteria are what a design must do.?
Constraints are the colors you like best.?
People's needs and wants lead to new designs.?
WHY THIS EXERCISEEngineers name the problem, the criteria and the constraints first.

Pick your problem

This week you design a bike add-on.

Pick one problem: carrying things, being seen or rain.

Or pick another real bike problem you have noticed.

Your add-on will be a cardboard model. Models stay off real bikes.

Try it
Look at a bike with a grown-up, or at a bike picture.
Think: what problem could an add-on solve?
Write your problem as one sentence.
Add two criteria and two constraints.
Safety first
The bike stays standing still. A grown-up holds it.
Today is looking and writing only.

Problem named! Tomorrow we research and dream up many ideas.