← Back to course
1/6
Week 09 Β· Confident and Wrong

Monday

Smooth, sure and false
// Why smooth answers still need checking
⏱ about 20 min

Monday: Smooth, Sure and False

Rocket shakes the word cups from last week and draws slips. "Raven spots a comet," he reads.

"That sounds great. I will add it to the club report."

Raven checks the real mission log. "Wait. I never spotted a comet. You did, twice."

"But the sentence sounded so sure," Rocket says. "There was no maybe in it at all."

Nova drifts over the cups, her lights flickering. "The cups do not know who spotted what," she says.

"They only know which words tend to follow which. So how sure should a sentence sound before you trust it?"

Confident is not the same as correct

NIST's Generative AI Profile describes a risk it calls confabulation.

Confabulation is when generative AI confidently states something that is wrong or false.

People often call this a "hallucination" or a "fabrication".

NIST says confabulations are a natural result of how generative models are designed.

  • Confident: the answer sounds sure, with no doubt in it.
  • Correct: the answer matches what is really true.
  • A generative AI answer can be confident and correct, or confident and wrong.
CONFIDENT, CORRECT, OR BOTH?
  • Read the question.
  • Tap your answer.
The cups write "Raven spots a comet", but the log says she never did. What is this?
The cups write "Rocket spots a comet", and the log agrees. What is this?
How could you tell the two sentences apart just by how they sound?
StatementTrue or false?
Confabulation means stating something false with confidence.?
If an AI answer sounds sure, it must be true.?
People often call confabulation a "hallucination".?
Confabulation is a natural result of how generative models are designed.?
WHY THIS EXERCISEGenerative AI can sound equally sure whether it is right or wrong.

A word worth questioning

NIST notes that some people think "hallucination" is a misleading word.

It makes the AI sound like a person who sees things. Real AI is a tool that people build, not a mind.

NIST's Generative AI Profile uses the word confabulation for this risk.

What word does NIST use for confidently stated but false AI content? Type one word.
WHY THIS EXERCISEConfabulation is NIST's word for confident, false generative AI content.
Try it
Say one true sentence and one false sentence in the exact same confident voice to someone nearby.
Can they tell which is which without checking?

Sharp start. Tomorrow you find out why prediction can land on a false sentence.